On this page
Choose an SEO agency that can show you past results, follows Google Search Essentials, tells you every change it makes to your site, and sets realistic timelines without guaranteeing rankings. In 2026, add one more test: ask how it tracks your visibility in AI Overviews and AI assistants, and what it does when that number moves.
I’ve sat on both sides of this decision. I’ve answered plenty of agency questionnaires, and I’ve helped companies clean up after a hire that didn’t work out. The questions below are the ones we’d want any prospect to ask before signing with an SEO agency, including us.
Most of them come straight from Google’s published guidance on hiring an SEO. The rest cover AI search, because a 2026 search program that ignores ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and AI Overviews is only measuring half of where your buyers ask questions.
What does an SEO agency actually do in 2026?
An SEO agency makes your site easy for search engines to crawl, understand and trust, then builds the content that earns rankings and citations for the questions your buyers ask. The core job hasn’t changed much. What’s changed is where the answers show up, so a good agency now measures AI answers alongside traditional rankings.
My view: AI search is mostly SEO with extra steps. The fundamentals still carry the weight. Clean site architecture, one clear purpose per page, fast templates, and in-depth content that answers a real question are what we see pages that get cited have in common.
Here’s what the work should include, and what you should be able to see from each piece of it.
| Workstream | What it includes | What you should see |
|---|---|---|
| Technical SEO | Crawlability, indexation, site speed, redirects, internal linking, structured data, duplicate pages, multiple H1s | A prioritized fix list and a log of what shipped |
| Content | Keyword and prompt research, new pages, refreshes of weak pages, consolidation of overlapping pages | A content calendar tied to specific queries and business goals |
| On-page optimization | Titles, headings, answer-first copy, internal links, page purpose | Before-and-after records for every page changed |
| Local SEO | Business profiles, location pages, reviews, listing accuracy | Listing audits and location-level reporting |
| AI search visibility | Tracking mentions and citations in AI answers, fixing the pages and third-party sources AI engines draw from | A baseline and a trend line, by engine |
| Reporting and strategy | Revenue or lead reporting, quarterly roadmaps, proactive recommendations | Reports that connect work to outcomes, not just activity |
If you have physical locations, local search deserves its own line in the proposal. We treat local SEO as a separate workstream because the data sources, listings and review platforms are different from the rest of the site.
Which questions should you ask an SEO agency before you sign?
Start with the questions Google itself recommends asking, then add five about AI search. Google’s guide Do you need an SEO? lays out a short list for business owners, and it holds up well. I’d use it as the floor, not the ceiling.
The questions from Google’s hiring guidance
- Can you show me examples of past work and success stories? Google suggests asking for them. A good agency shows results in business terms (revenue, leads, bookings) and explains what it changed to get there. Be wary of a case study that only shows traffic graphs.
- “Do you follow the Google Search Essentials?” That’s Google’s wording. The answer should be an easy yes, followed by specifics about how they handle links, content and structured data.
- “What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe?” Listen for a range tied to your site’s starting point. A precise promise is a warning sign; a shrug is too.
- Will you share all the changes you make to my site? Google recommends asking this. The only acceptable answer is yes, with a change log you can read.
- Can I talk to current or past clients? Google advises checking references. Ask the reference what the agency did when results stalled, because that tells you more than what it did when things went well.
Five more questions for AI search
Google’s list covers the fundamentals well. These five fill the gap for AI answers, and the right column shows what a strong answer sounds like versus a weak one.
| Question | Strong answer | Weak answer |
|---|---|---|
| Which AI engines do you track, and how often? | Names specific engines and a set of tracked prompts, measured on a schedule | “We monitor AI” with no engines or prompts named |
| Do you separate mentions from citations? | Yes: a mention is your brand named in the answer, a citation is your page linked as a source, and they move differently | Treats them as the same number |
| What’s my baseline today? | Can show where you stand before any work starts | Plans to start measuring after the work begins |
| Which pages would you change first for AI answers, and why? | Points to specific pages and the questions they should answer | Recommends a new file, tool or schema type as the main fix |
| What won’t you do to get us cited? | Rules out fake reviews, planted forum posts and invented author credentials | Has no answer, or says “whatever works” |
For reference, here’s how we’d answer the first two. Our AI search optimization work tracks five engines (ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode) and reports mentions and citations separately, benchmarked against 55 brands. That’s not the only valid setup, but any agency you hire should be able to describe its own setup at that level of detail.
If AI visibility is your main concern rather than one part of a broader SEO program, we wrote a separate guide on how to choose an AI SEO agency with twelve questions specific to that work.
What are the red flags when hiring an SEO agency?
The biggest red flags are guaranteed rankings, requests for full control of your accounts before you’ve seen any work, and link building that sounds like buying links. Each one tells you the agency is optimizing for the sale, not for your site.
Guaranteed rankings or guaranteed AI citations
Google is direct about this in its hiring guide: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.” The same logic applies to AI answers, which change by prompt, by engine and sometimes by the hour. An agency that guarantees a position is either planning to pick a keyword nobody searches or isn’t being straight with you.
Write access before trust
Google suggests giving a prospective SEO read-only access to Search Console while they audit your site, rather than full permissions. That’s a sensible default for everything: analytics, Search Console, your CMS. Expand access once you’ve agreed on the work and seen how they handle what they have.
The flip side matters just as much. Your accounts should stay in your name. If an agency sets up analytics, Search Console or your ad accounts under its own ownership, you’ll have a hard time leaving, and that’s often the point.
Link schemes dressed up as outreach
In our experience, the link offers that cause trouble usually come with a price per link, a guaranteed number of links per month, or a list of sites that exist mostly to sell placements. Ask exactly how links are earned. If the answer involves paying site owners for followed links, walk away.
The rest of the list
| Red flag | Why it matters | What to ask instead |
|---|---|---|
| Reports lead with impressions or “optimizations made” | Activity and big denominators hide whether anything improved | “Show me how this report connects to revenue or leads.” |
| A “secret” or proprietary method they can’t explain | If the name does more work than the method, there isn’t much method | “Walk me through what you’d change on our site in month one.” |
| A special AI file or markup sold as the main AI search fix | No single file gets you cited; the content and the sources around it do | “What pages and third-party sources would you work on?” |
| Long contracts with no exit clause | Lock-in replaces performance as the reason you stay | “What happens if we want to leave after a quarter?” |
| Blames the last agency for everything | It tells you how they’ll talk about you later, and it skips the real technical cause | “What specifically is broken, and how do you know?” |
Should you hire an SEO agency, a freelancer or an in-house SEO?
Hire an agency when you need several specialties at once, a freelancer when you need one skill for a defined project, and an in-house SEO when search is a daily, core part of how you make money. Plenty of companies end up with a mix, and that’s often the right answer.
| Factor | SEO agency | Freelancer | In-house SEO |
|---|---|---|---|
| Range of skills | Technical, content, local, analytics and AI search under one roof | Usually deep in one or two areas | Depends on the hire; one person rarely covers everything |
| Business context | Builds over time through onboarding and regular meetings | Limited to the project scope | Highest; they sit with your team every day |
| Speed to start | Fast; the team and tools already exist | Fast for a narrow project | Slow; recruiting and ramp-up take time |
| Continuity | Coverage when someone is out or leaves | Single point of failure | Risk if the one person leaves |
| Tools and data | Included in the engagement | Varies | You buy and maintain them |
| Best fit | Growing companies that need strategy and execution across channels | Defined projects like a migration audit or a content sprint | Large sites where search is a primary revenue channel |
The hybrid model works well for a lot of mid-size teams. An in-house marketer owns priorities and business context, and the agency supplies specialist depth: technical SEO, AI search tracking, analytics and content production. If you go this route, settle who owns which decisions in writing during the first month. Larger organizations need even more of that structure; our guide to enterprise SEO covers it.
What should the first 90 days with an SEO agency look like?
The first 90 days should produce a baseline, a ranked list of fixes, and the first shipped changes, not just an audit PDF. If the only deliverable at day 90 is a document, the clock on results hasn’t really started.
We run engagements on what we call the Growth Engine: annual goals, a quarterly roadmap, and weekly working cycles. Whatever an agency calls its process, you should recognize something like this sequence:
- Weeks 1 to 2: access and baseline. Read-only access to analytics and Search Console first, then a baseline of rankings, organic revenue or leads, and AI visibility by engine.
- Weeks 2 to 4: audit and priorities. A technical and content audit, ranked by impact and effort, with a clear owner for every item.
- Weeks 4 to 8: ship the infrastructure fixes. The boring work: broken redirects, duplicate pages, multiple H1s, thin pages, internal links. This is usually where the earliest movement comes from. For a real example, see how we handled redirects when we moved sentic.io from Webflow to WordPress.
- Weeks 6 to 10: first content. Refresh the pages closest to ranking, then publish new pages built around the questions buyers actually ask.
- Weeks 10 to 12: review and plan the next quarter. Compare against the baseline, say plainly what worked and what didn’t, and update keyword targets and tracked prompts.
A lot of agencies tell clients to wait six to twelve months before expecting anything. I think that’s often an excuse. When the infrastructure is fixed early and the content targets real demand, we tend to see directional movement well before that, though the size and speed always depend on where the site starts.
The results that matter are business results. One hospitality brand we work with grew revenue 445% year over year; you can see how we report outcomes like that on our results page. Ask every agency you talk to for numbers in that form, and ask what they changed to get them.
Use this checklist to compare SEO agencies
Print this, or paste it into a doc, and score each agency on the same items after your calls. Any agency that misses more than two or three of these is probably not the right fit.
Proof and transparency
- Shared examples of past work with business outcomes, not just traffic
- Gave references you could actually contact
- Confirmed it follows Google Search Essentials, with specifics
- Committed to sharing every change it makes to your site
- Set a realistic timeline range tied to your starting point
- Did not guarantee rankings or AI citations
Ownership and access
- Asked for read-only access during the audit phase
- Confirmed all accounts stay in your company’s name
- Explained its exit terms in plain language
AI search
- Named the AI engines it tracks
- Reports mentions and citations separately
- Will set a baseline before work starts
- Named specific pages it would work on first
- Ruled out fake reviews, planted posts and invented credentials
Process and reporting
- Described what the first 90 days produce, week by week
- Reports connect work to revenue or leads
- Updates keyword targets and prompts at least quarterly
- Brings recommendations to you instead of waiting for requests
- Has a clear plan for local search if you have locations
Frequently asked questions
How long does it take an SEO agency to show results?
It depends on your site’s starting point and competition. In our experience, fixing technical problems early can produce directional movement within the first quarter, while larger gains from new content build over the following quarters.
Can an SEO agency guarantee first-page rankings?
No. Google states that no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google, and any agency that promises one is a risk to your site.
Do I need a separate agency for AI search?
Not necessarily. AI search builds on the same fundamentals as SEO, so one agency can handle both, as long as it tracks AI mentions and citations as their own metrics.
Who should own my analytics and Search Console accounts?
You should. Give the agency the access it needs, starting with read-only during the audit, but keep ownership in your company’s name.
What should an SEO agency report every month?
Revenue or leads from organic search, progress against the quarterly roadmap, the changes that shipped, and AI visibility trends. Impressions and task counts can sit in an appendix.
Want a second opinion before you hire?
If you’re comparing agencies, or wondering whether your current one is doing the work, start with a free growth audit. In about five business days you’ll get three to five ranked opportunities and a 90-day roadmap, and you can use it to pressure-test any proposal on your desk, including ours.