On this page
Hire an AI SEO agency that can show you exactly how it measures brand mentions and citations in ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews, explains every change it makes to your site, and refuses to guarantee placement. Google’s own hiring guidance says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, and AI answers are even less predictable than rankings.
Nearly every agency has added “AI” to its homepage lately, so the label tells you very little. I run the AI search practice at Sentic, and we’re an AI search optimization agency, so read this knowing that. I’ve tried to write the questions so they work just as well on us as on anyone else.
Below you’ll find what the service should include, 12 questions to ask on the sales call, the red flags that should end the conversation, a scorecard you can copy into a spreadsheet, and a realistic timeline for results.
Are AEO, GEO and AI SEO different services?
No, for buying purposes they’re the same service with different names. Answer engine optimization (AEO), generative engine optimization (GEO), AI SEO, LLM optimization and AI visibility all describe the work of getting your brand named and cited in answers generated by AI tools.
The terms came from different places. GEO comes from academic research: a 2023 paper by Aggarwal and colleagues, “GEO: Generative Engine Optimization”, found that GEO methods can boost visibility by up to 40% in generative engine responses. AEO grew out of the featured snippet and voice search era. AI SEO is mostly what buyers type into Google.
If an agency tells you GEO and AEO are fundamentally different disciplines and you need both, ask what changes in the actual deliverables. In my experience the answer is usually “the invoice.” Our AI search glossary covers the vocabulary if you want to check whether a proposal is using terms precisely or decoratively.
What matters more than the label is the relationship to traditional SEO. On the Google side especially, AI search is SEO with extra steps. Google states plainly that there are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, nor other special optimizations necessary, beyond being indexed and eligible to show with a snippet. So an AI SEO agency that can’t do solid technical and content SEO is building on sand. Our guide on how to choose an SEO agency covers that side of the evaluation.
What should an AI SEO agency actually deliver?
An AI SEO agency should deliver four things: a measured baseline of your AI visibility, a prioritized plan tied to the questions your buyers ask, the on-site and off-site work to execute that plan, and recurring reporting that separates mentions from citations. If any of those four is missing, you’re buying part of a service.
Here’s what each piece looks like in practice.
| Deliverable | What good looks like | What weak looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Baseline | A fixed prompt set run across named AI engines, with your mention and citation share recorded against competitors before any work starts | A few screenshots of ChatGPT answers, no competitors, no repeatable method |
| Prompt and keyword research | Questions mapped to real buyer stages, refreshed each quarter | A keyword list from three years ago with “AI” added to the title |
| On-site work | Fixing thin pages, heading structure, internal links, indexation, and rewriting key pages so they answer questions directly | Adding new files or schema types and calling it optimization |
| Off-site work | Earning accurate coverage in the third-party sources AI tools already cite for your category | Mass posting on forums or buying listicle placements |
| Reporting | Mentions, citations, AI referral traffic and leads or revenue, with the change log next to the numbers | Activity counts: “we made 140 optimizations this month” |
The distinction between mentions and citations matters more than most proposals admit. A mention is when the AI names your brand in the answer. A citation is when it links to your site as a source. You can have plenty of one and almost none of the other, which is why our State of AI Visibility 2026 study tracks them separately across 55 brands.
For a worked example of how we structure this: our AEO program tracks five AI engines (ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode) and two metrics (mentions and citations), benchmarked against that 55-brand dataset. You don’t need to copy our setup. You should expect any agency to describe its own setup with the same level of specificity.
What are the 12 questions to ask an AI SEO agency?
Ask these 12 questions on the first or second call, and pay attention to how specific the answers are. Vague answers to measurement questions are the most reliable warning sign I know of. Several of these are adapted from Google’s own advice on hiring an SEO, which still holds up well for AI search.
- Which AI engines do you track, and how? A good answer names the engines and explains the method: a fixed set of prompts, run on a schedule, with results stored so they can be compared over time. A weak answer is “we monitor AI search.”
- Do you report mentions and citations separately? They behave differently and need different fixes. An agency that lumps them into one “AI visibility score” can’t tell you which problem you have.
- How do you build the prompt set, and how often does it change? Prompts should come from real buyer questions, sales calls and search data, not from the agency’s imagination. They should be reviewed at least quarterly, because the questions people ask keep moving.
- What will my baseline look like before you start? Ask to see a sample baseline report. If they can’t show one, they probably don’t build one, and without a baseline any later “improvement” is unverifiable.
- Do you follow Google Search Essentials? This one comes straight from Google’s hiring guidance. Since AI Overviews and AI Mode draw on the same index as Search, anything that breaks Google’s rules puts your AI visibility at risk too.
- What results do you expect, and in what timeframe? Also from Google’s list. You want a range and a reason, not a promise. We tell clients to expect directional wins in roughly six to eight weeks and measurable impact by around month three, and we explain what drives each.
- Will you share every change you make to my site? Google suggests asking this directly. The answer should be an unqualified yes, with a change log you can read without a login to the agency’s own tool.
- What access do you need during the audit? Google recommends giving read-only Search Console access while you evaluate an agency. If they need full admin rights to your site before you’ve signed anything, ask why.
- What does your off-site work actually involve? Ask for specifics: which kinds of publications, directories or communities, and how they earn placement. “We get you mentioned on Reddit” is not a plan.
- How do you connect AI visibility to leads or revenue? Citations are useful, but you’re paying for business outcomes. Ask how they track AI referral traffic and what they do about the visits that never click through.
- Can I talk to current clients? Google’s advice is to ask for examples and check references. Talk to someone who has been with them for at least two quarters, and ask whether reporting ever got uncomfortable and how the agency handled it.
- What happens to my data and accounts if we part ways? Every account, dashboard and tracking setup should be in your name or transferable to you. If the agency owns your analytics property, you’re renting your own history.
Write the answers down. You’ll use them in the scorecard further down.
What red flags should end the conversation?
Walk away from any agency that guarantees citations or placements, sells “secret” AI files as the core of its service, or can’t show you a baseline. Each of those tells you something about how the agency will report to you later.
Guaranteed citations or placements
Google is direct about this: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.” AI answers are generated fresh, vary by user and phrasing, and change as models update. An agency promising “guaranteed ChatGPT placement” is either measuring something trivial, like your brand name typed as the prompt, or setting up a report that flatters itself.
“Secret” or proprietary AI files
Some agencies sell special markup, hidden text, or AI-only files as the thing that gets you into AI answers. Google says no special optimizations are needed for AI Overviews and AI Mode. Files like llms.txt can be a reasonable low-cost addition for other AI tools, which we cover in our guide to llms.txt, but they are not a strategy and nobody should be charging you a premium for them.
No baseline, no competitors
If the first report shows you “now appearing in AI answers” without a before picture, there’s no way to know what the agency caused. The same goes for reports with no competitor context. Your mention share means one thing when your top competitor trails you and something very different when it’s named in nearly every answer.
Activity dressed as outcome
“We published 12 articles and made 200 optimizations” describes effort, not results. Reports should lead with what changed in mentions, citations, traffic and leads, then show the work that plausibly caused it.
Shotgun off-site tactics
Posting across forums for the sake of volume, sockpuppet accounts, invented author credentials and review schema on content that doesn’t contain reviews all fall in this bucket. Beyond the ethical problem, manufactured signals poison the measurement. If the agency created the citations, the report can’t tell you whether your brand actually earned visibility.
How do you compare AI SEO agency proposals?
Score each proposal on the same criteria, weight measurement and transparency most heavily, and don’t let price or polish override a weak score on either. The table below is built to paste into a spreadsheet: score each agency 1 to 5 on each line and multiply by the weight.
| Criterion | Weight | What a 5 looks like | Agency A | Agency B | Agency C |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Named AI engines tracked | 3 | Lists each engine and explains the method | |||
| Mentions and citations reported separately | 3 | Separate metrics, with competitor share | |||
| Baseline before work starts | 3 | Sample baseline report provided | |||
| Prompt set refreshed regularly | 2 | Quarterly review built into the plan | |||
| Technical and content SEO depth | 3 | Specific examples of fixing site infrastructure | |||
| Change log shared with you | 3 | Every change listed, readable by you | |||
| Off-site plan is specific | 2 | Names source types and how placement is earned | |||
| Ties visibility to leads or revenue | 3 | Shows AI referral tracking and conversion reporting | |||
| Realistic timeline with reasoning | 2 | Ranges, not promises, with the why | |||
| You own all accounts and data | 3 | Written into the agreement | |||
| References from current clients | 2 | Two or more, willing to take a call | |||
| No guarantees of placement | 3 | Says plainly that nobody can guarantee it |
Two quick notes on using it. First, any agency that scores a 1 on “no guarantees” or “you own all accounts” should be out regardless of the total. Second, score after the call, not during it, because a confident presenter can make a vague answer sound specific in the moment.
It also helps to ask each agency which tools it uses for tracking and why. There are good options at different budgets, and we compare several in our roundup of the best AEO tools. An agency that can explain why it picked its stack, including the limits of that stack, usually understands the measurement problem well.
What results should you expect from an AI SEO agency, and when?
Expect early directional movement in mentions and citations within a couple of months and clearer business impact around the end of the first quarter, assuming the site’s technical foundation is in reasonable shape. Anyone promising dramatic results in two weeks is guessing, and anyone telling you to wait a full year before you see anything is padding the runway.
In our AEO engagements, we typically see directional wins in about six to eight weeks and measurable impact by around month three. That’s a pattern, not a promise. It depends on how much infrastructure work the site needs, how competitive the category is, and how quickly changes can get published.
Here’s how I’d think about the first 90 days.
| Period | What should happen | What you should see |
|---|---|---|
| Weeks 1 to 2 | Baseline across engines, prompt set agreed, technical and content audit | A baseline report and a ranked list of fixes |
| Weeks 3 to 6 | Priority technical fixes, rewrites of the pages that should answer your top questions, first off-site outreach | A change log and early shifts on specific prompts |
| Weeks 7 to 12 | Second wave of content, expanded off-site work, first quarterly review of prompts | Mention and citation trends against baseline, AI referral traffic and leads |
Because AI answers vary, a single run of a single prompt tells you almost nothing. Look for trends across the full prompt set over several weeks. A good agency will tell you which movements it thinks are noise, which is the opposite of a report built to flatter.
One last thing: the boring work is usually what moves the numbers. Fixing thin pages, cleaning up heading structure, making each page serve one clear purpose and rewriting key pages to answer questions directly will do more for your AI visibility than any new tactic you saw on LinkedIn this week. If an agency’s plan skips straight to the novel stuff, ask what it plans to do about the foundation.
FAQ
Is an AI SEO agency different from a regular SEO agency?
It should be a regular SEO agency that also measures and works on AI visibility. AI search on Google uses the same index and the same eligibility rules as Search, so the skills overlap heavily; the differences are in prompt research, mention and citation tracking, and off-site work.
Can an agency guarantee my brand will appear in ChatGPT?
No. AI answers vary by phrasing, user and model version, and Google’s own hiring advice says no one can guarantee a top ranking. Treat any guarantee as a red flag about how the agency will report to you.
How long does AI SEO take to show results?
In our engagements, directional wins usually show up in about six to eight weeks, with measurable impact around month three. Sites that need heavy technical cleanup first can take longer.
Do I need special AI files or schema to show up in AI Overviews?
No. Google says there are no additional requirements or special optimizations needed for AI Overviews or AI Mode beyond being indexed and eligible to show with a snippet.
What should I give an agency access to during evaluation?
Read-only Search Console access is enough for an audit, which is what Google recommends. Save broader access for after you’ve signed and know who will be making changes.
Want to see where you stand first?
If you’d like a baseline before you talk to anyone, including us, request a free growth audit. You’ll get 3 to 5 ranked opportunities and a 90-day roadmap in about five business days, and it’s yours to keep whichever agency you choose.